lifter ticking, thick oil possible issue?
#1
lifter ticking, thick oil possible issue?
I am getting a lifter tick on my fresh rebuilt 350. My builder recommended I run 20w-50 oil in the engine. That is what was put in for the break in and it I still have it in there. I know that is not what is recommended to run from the factory manual and although my engine isn't a completely stock rebuild it is a pretty mild build about 325 horse. It has stock lifters that are not adjustable and I have read that sometimes these engines have been known to have a problem pumping oil up to the lifters. So my question is could this thick oil be the problem here? Is it necessary to run that thick of oil, or should I try running some 10w-30 and see if the tick goes away? My builder said he is willing to take care of the problem whatever it takes but I thought maybe this would be an easy thing to try first. I don't want to drop my car off to him and not get it back for a couple weeks. Any thoughts would be appreciated. And just to be clear we have pin pointed it to a lifter tick and not leaking headers.
#2
20W-50 is too thick for this motor. 10W-40 would be better, though straight 30 weight is what you should use for break-in. Did you use any kind of zinc additive or high-zinc oil for cam break-in? Were the lifters pre-lubed before installation? Did you properly prime the oil pump before any new start? Did the machine shop properly set the valve stem heights to factory spec?
#3
20W-50 is too thick for this motor. 10W-40 would be better, though straight 30 weight is what you should use for break-in. Did you use any kind of zinc additive or high-zinc oil for cam break-in? Were the lifters pre-lubed before installation? Did you properly prime the oil pump before any new start? Did the machine shop properly set the valve stem heights to factory spec?
Last edited by Finn5033; June 10th, 2013 at 08:34 AM.
#4
I have a similar issue with my 350 as well. My issue though is with the rockers. I have adjusted them at least three times and after a few miles they start clacking again. I have been told to run a heavier 50 weight oil too because of oil pressure issues. I have noticed that there does not seem to be a lot of oil making its way to the heads when we were adjusting the rockers.
This build was a little more agressive than stock. The engine builder says this is all normal but I'm not buying it.
This build was a little more agressive than stock. The engine builder says this is all normal but I'm not buying it.
#5
I have a similar issue with my 350 as well. My issue though is with the rockers. I have adjusted them at least three times and after a few miles they start clacking again. I have been told to run a heavier 50 weight oil too because of oil pressure issues. I have noticed that there does not seem to be a lot of oil making its way to the heads when we were adjusting the rockers.
This build was a little more agressive than stock. The engine builder says this is all normal but I'm not buying it.
This build was a little more agressive than stock. The engine builder says this is all normal but I'm not buying it.
#7
Agreed. This is not normal. A tick is too much clearance period. Whether it be a collapsed lifter, bad rocker bent push rod or incorrect stem height. That shouldn't/cant be made up with oil viscosity. 20W50 is too thick. 15W40 is about as heavy as one should go on a street driven car in a moderate to hot climate. On a brand new motor 10W30 to 10W40 for break in depending on how tight the clearances are. Never have I run 50 weight on anything for break in period or any other time. That even applies to the 10K & 20K CI engines.
#8
I think I understand what your saying Joe, but if I knew how to do this myself I would. Meaning all I can do is trust that he knew what he was doing, not sure how I can verify that? Assuming your talking about the engine specs and not just the oil. Just to be clear there is no sarcasm meant here just wondering what I can do to verify.
Last edited by Finn5033; June 10th, 2013 at 10:20 AM.
#9
Agreed. This is not normal. A tick is too much clearance period. Whether it be a collapsed lifter, bad rocker bent push rod or incorrect stem height. That shouldn't/cant be made up with oil viscosity. 20W50 is too thick. 15W40 is about as heavy as one should go on a street driven car in a moderate to hot climate. On a brand new motor 10W30 to 10W40 for break in depending on how tight the clearances are. Never have I run 50 weight on anything for break in period or any other time. That even applies to the 10K & 20K CI engines.
Last edited by Finn5033; June 10th, 2013 at 09:58 AM.
#10
I'd be leery of an engine builder that told me to run 20-50 in a new engine. My builder told me to use Joe Gibbs straight 30 brake in oil for the first 500 and then change over to 5 or 10-30, I used 10-30 oil in it and it carries 60 PSI with a stock pump. I had a couple of ticks from the valve train on start up when the engine was new, now that it has 2500 on it, it never makes any noise.
#11
I'd be leery of an engine builder that told me to run 20-50 in a new engine. My builder told me to use Joe Gibbs straight 30 brake in oil for the first 500 and then change over to 5 or 10-30, I used 10-30 oil in it and it carries 60 PSI with a stock pump. I had a couple of ticks from the valve train on start up when the engine was new, now that it has 2500 on it, it never makes any noise.
#12
I think I understand what your saying Joe, but if I knew how to do this myself I would. Meaning all I can do is trust that he knew what he was doing, not sure how I can verify that? Assuming your talking about the engine specs and not just the oil. Just to be clear there is no sarcasm meant here just wondering what I can do to verify.
#13
This comes up a lot due to the large number of Chevy-centric machine shops out there. Since they are used to Chevy's adjustable rockers, few take the time to ensure that the valve tips on Olds heads are set to the factory spec necessary to work with the non-adjustable valvetrain. Of course, this could be caused by a different problem, but this is a common one.
Last edited by Finn5033; June 10th, 2013 at 11:05 AM.
#14
When he rebuilt the engine, did he replace all the rockers and perches? Were the heads milled? X2 on Joes question, did he cut all the valve stems to the proper length and are they all the same?
I agree with everyone else on the 20-50 oil also.
I agree with everyone else on the 20-50 oil also.
Last edited by oldcutlass; June 10th, 2013 at 11:26 AM.
#15
The head work was done to accomodate big block valves, they were not milled. He said the rockers were in great shape so he reused them. Not sure about the perches.
#16
Ok, I see what your saying. I think what I will do is change the oil, pull the valve covers and make sure they are torqued correctly and go from there. My builder said he would correct the issue, I just wanted to see if it was something I could maybe take care of so I didn't have to be without my car for a while. My main concern is just that it is taken care of correctly.
#18
#19
So are you guys saying that even on an older motor with 30-40k miles one shouldn't be using 20w-50? I use it right now on my 69 350 2bl stock and it seems to quiet down the motor quite a bit. Should I go to a 10-40 instead as I may be damaging the motor? not meant to hijack just a query.
#21
If the valve train is not set up correctly it will be nothing but trouble. As many have mentioned if the machinist inst knowledgeable on Olds specific valve trains it will never be right. You could have something else going on so some good trouble shooting will find where the problem is.
#22
So are you guys saying that even on an older motor with 30-40k miles one shouldn't be using 20w-50? I use it right now on my 69 350 2bl stock and it seems to quiet down the motor quite a bit. Should I go to a 10-40 instead as I may be damaging the motor? not meant to hijack just a query.
#23
Are they all clattering or just one or two? You could just have a bad trunnion or lifter? Trouble shoot before R&R.
#24
#25
Figured out the issue last night. Pulled the valve cover and one of the rockers was very sloppy. Turned out my builder had put the wrong length push rod in on one of them. Got the correct one and the tick is gone.
Question on the oil now though, I did do an oil change to 10w-30. I'm at 50 psi pressure at start up, once warmed up to temp the pressure is around 25psi at idle, around 40 when cruising. Does that seem too low? should I run something thicker?
Question on the oil now though, I did do an oil change to 10w-30. I'm at 50 psi pressure at start up, once warmed up to temp the pressure is around 25psi at idle, around 40 when cruising. Does that seem too low? should I run something thicker?
Last edited by Finn5033; June 14th, 2013 at 05:41 AM.
#26
"I'm at 50 psi pressure at start up, once warmed up to temp the pressure is around 25psi at idle, around 40 when cruising. Does that seem too low? should I run something thicker?"
In my opinion you're fine with those oil pressures.
In my opinion you're fine with those oil pressures.
#27
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
monzaz
Parts For Sale
0
November 14th, 2012 07:20 PM