Pre-Ignition, How to detect?
#1
Pre-Ignition, How to detect?
How do you detect pre-ignition? I know the obvious is to hear it but is it possible to have it and not here is? I thought I read somewhere that it is harder to hear on an aluminum engine, is this true?
I can not here any hint of it on our Jetfire but it is an aluminum engine with 10:1 compression and 6.5 psi of boost. It does inject water to cool the intake air when it is working correct. Yesterday I was doing some testing and put a heavy load on it to get it to boost but I had the water deactivated. I did not go to full boost but likely around 3 psi. I still did not hear any knock. I just want to be sure I am not doing harm to the engine by thinking things are fine because I can't hear a knock.
I can not here any hint of it on our Jetfire but it is an aluminum engine with 10:1 compression and 6.5 psi of boost. It does inject water to cool the intake air when it is working correct. Yesterday I was doing some testing and put a heavy load on it to get it to boost but I had the water deactivated. I did not go to full boost but likely around 3 psi. I still did not hear any knock. I just want to be sure I am not doing harm to the engine by thinking things are fine because I can't hear a knock.
#2
Preignition and detonation are 2 different things. Preignition is something that happens prior to the spark plug firing and detonation is after. Inspecting the spark plugs for extremely burned ends or deterioration of the ceramic is a good indication of preignition. I would think you need to keep the rocket fluid injection operating as that is the only way to cool the mixture to prevent it using recommended tuneup settings.
#3
The only way that I know of to reliably sense detonation is with a detonation sensor that is bolted to the head, as they have on newer computer controlled cars.
With all of the other noises inherent in driving (tire noise, wind noise, exhaust noise, mechanical engine noise), it is impossible to reliably hear it.
I know that they do sell sensors and computer units that can be retrofitted, but I believe that they are expensive, and I know nothing about them.
Failing that, set timing to factory spec, use fuel with the required octane rating, be sure water injection is functioning properly, and keep your ears open.
- Eric
With all of the other noises inherent in driving (tire noise, wind noise, exhaust noise, mechanical engine noise), it is impossible to reliably hear it.
I know that they do sell sensors and computer units that can be retrofitted, but I believe that they are expensive, and I know nothing about them.
Failing that, set timing to factory spec, use fuel with the required octane rating, be sure water injection is functioning properly, and keep your ears open.
- Eric
#4
use meth injection...snow is the best on the planet..google it..meth adds tons of octane...and theres a diff between real meth and window washer fluid...
you have water injection already..meth is water on steroids..
theres so much going on you really need to research it
theres a lot of myths about turbos...if you keep it out of detonation, they are extremely easy on engines...
its hard to tell if its detonating or not..better to be safe , or that is pro-active instead of reactive...
reading plugs goes a long way...theres tons of info on it too
you have water injection already..meth is water on steroids..
theres so much going on you really need to research it
theres a lot of myths about turbos...if you keep it out of detonation, they are extremely easy on engines...
its hard to tell if its detonating or not..better to be safe , or that is pro-active instead of reactive...
reading plugs goes a long way...theres tons of info on it too
Last edited by marxjunk; August 7th, 2016 at 02:38 PM.
#5
use meth injection...snow is the best on the planet..google it..meth adds tons of octane...and theres a diff between real meth and window washer fluid...
you have water injection already..meth is water on steroids..
theres so much going on you really need to research it
theres a lot of myths about turbos...if you keep it out of detonation, they are extremely easy on engines...
its hard to tell if its detonating or not..better to be safe , or that is pro-active instead of reactive...
reading plugs goes a long way...theres tons of info on it too
you have water injection already..meth is water on steroids..
theres so much going on you really need to research it
theres a lot of myths about turbos...if you keep it out of detonation, they are extremely easy on engines...
its hard to tell if its detonating or not..better to be safe , or that is pro-active instead of reactive...
reading plugs goes a long way...theres tons of info on it too
I don't believe this car is detonating but I have no experience with aluminum engines. I read someplace that it is hard to hear an aluminum engine detonating, I just don't know if that is true. I am running a 160 T stat and it stays there most of the time. On a real hot day and in town it will get to 190. I typically don't let it boost much till it is back down to 170 or less just to help. I know that is not cylinder temp but it is still going to be cooler a little.
#7
93 is the highest I can get at the pump. Can't afford race gas. As long as the water is working properly I should not have a problem. Would be nice if 110 was less money because I could just run that and skip the water.
Last edited by jensenracing77; August 7th, 2016 at 05:19 PM.
#8
Preignition and detonation are 2 different things. Preignition is something that happens prior to the spark plug firing and detonation is after. Inspecting the spark plugs for extremely burned ends or deterioration of the ceramic is a good indication of preignition. I would think you need to keep the rocket fluid injection operating as that is the only way to cool the mixture to prevent it using recommended tuneup settings.
If your octane is to low it will be hard to start and hard to keep running until warm.
Railguy
#10
#11
Only factory gauge is vacuum/boost but it don't have numbers on it. I added a temp gauge and for a short while I had an accurate vacuum pressure gauge on it to know where my factory gauge was at different PSI.
#12
ive had alum engine buicks my whole life..and the only thing i did was once in awhile pull a plug and use a magnifying glass and make sure there was absolutely no alum specks on the plug...its all i could do...modern alum engines run at about 215deg i think...i think you are over thinking it
you can run 1 full point higher with alum than iron heads...as far as the block who cares..it has liners..so the piston doesnt know its an alum block.
detonation beats the pistons and bearing out of the motor..kills the ring lands..and if you cant hear it..you cant fight it..
my advice...keep it tuned..keep it full of meth and enjoy it...remember the meth adds a lot of octane..and the water with the meth is chemical inter cooling...plus its draw thru..so even the fuel is like a chemical inter cooling agent..if you want i will send a pm with an in depth discussion on a scientific level..article i found on line
you can run 1 full point higher with alum than iron heads...as far as the block who cares..it has liners..so the piston doesnt know its an alum block.
detonation beats the pistons and bearing out of the motor..kills the ring lands..and if you cant hear it..you cant fight it..
my advice...keep it tuned..keep it full of meth and enjoy it...remember the meth adds a lot of octane..and the water with the meth is chemical inter cooling...plus its draw thru..so even the fuel is like a chemical inter cooling agent..if you want i will send a pm with an in depth discussion on a scientific level..article i found on line
Last edited by marxjunk; August 7th, 2016 at 08:15 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post