When deciding to keep the car remember that you can get alot of enjoyment from a car even if it isn't a 442 or convertible. I would keep the car if it only has 58,000 mi. on it. Then again, if you have no use for it you should consider selling it as long as you get the right price for it. It would be a shame to sell the car and not get a decent amount of money for it. Hopefully you can post some pics and we can see what kind of beauty you have.
Welcome to the site.